Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision Homes for Sale

Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision Homes for Sale

Welcome to Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lee County, Florida. This enchanting community offers a unique blend of tranquility and modern living, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a serene lifestyle without sacrificing convenience.

As you explore the homes for sale in Castaway Key, you'll discover a variety of charming residences that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. Each home is thoughtfully designed, boasting spacious layouts, contemporary finishes, and inviting outdoor spaces perfect for enjoying the beautiful Florida sunshine. Whether you’re looking for a cozy retreat or a family-friendly abode, Castaway Key has something for everyone.

The location of this subdivision is simply unbeatable. With easy access to stunning beaches, vibrant shopping districts, and a plethora of dining options, residents can enjoy the best of Florida living. Imagine taking leisurely strolls along the coastline, indulging in fresh seafood at local restaurants, or spending weekends exploring nearby parks and recreational areas.

Community spirit thrives in Castaway Key, where neighbors become friends and every day feels like a vacation. With a strong sense of belonging, residents often gather for community events and activities, fostering connections that last a lifetime.

If you’re ready to embark on a new chapter in your life, Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision is the perfect place to call home. Explore the homes for sale today and discover the enchanting lifestyle that awaits you in this idyllic Florida community!

Newest Castaway Key Unrecorded Subdivision Homes for Sale

$1,490,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026023102 MLS
UPPER CAPTIVA CANAL HOME. Beautiful private views across the State Park to Pine Island from this gorgeous 3 bedroom plus a den & 3.5 bathroom home. It has everything you would want from an island home including protected docking for your boats on a navigable canal which leads out to the Gulf of Mexico and the Intracoastal Waterway, an elevator to bring groceries and supplies up to the kitchen, all windows are hurricane impact windows, cedar ship-lap exterior siding, wood burning fireplace, an upper mezzanine area above the living room which could be a studio or office, plenty of room for guests, a beautiful kitchen with big windows showing the view to the State Park, wide decks wrap around the house on both floors, a large screened-in pool with a shower and bathroom, new electric system inside and out, new roof, newly painted decks, newly painted exterior. Also, recent maintenance check on the Elevator. The beach is just down the sandy path to a parking area with access to the widest beach on the island. This island home could be an exceptional income producing property. Please make an appointment to see this wonderful home soon.

621 Rum Road, Captiva
$999,999
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026014378 MLS
Exceptional Double-Lot Island Retreat! Ideally positioned on a rare double lot, this beautifully maintained North Captiva Island home offers enhanced privacy, extra space, and low-maintenance coastal living. This North Captiva retreat offers more than just a home; it presents a rare opportunity for the lucky buyer to own an exclusive separate membership in Captiva Castaway Beach. Just a short, scenic stroll from your front door, this membership grants you deeded access to arguably the finest 'sugar sand' private beach on the island. Enjoy this ultimate Gulf-front luxury beach with its pristine, secluded shoreline reserved for a select few, ensuring your piece of paradise remains private and protected for years to come. Designed with a reverse floorplan, the home is filled with natural light and opens to lush tropical surroundings. The main living area, with its full-length sliding glass wall, allows the inside to flow seamlessly onto a spacious screened lanai (with premium “no-see-um” screen comfort) for bug-free open-air entertaining, lounging on the double hammock, or just enjoying the soft gulf breezes, creating indoor-outdoor living ideal for any occasion. The galley-style kitchen features a generous dining bar and walk-in pantry, while two private primary suites with en-suite baths and walk-in showers offer comfort and privacy. A versatile bunk room serves as a fourth sleeping area for additional guests. Extensive exterior “maintenance-free” recent upgrades set this home apart: impact-resistant doors and sliders, PGT energy-efficient low-E impact windows, composite decking, powder-coated aluminum railings, and premium composite siding (rated for up to 150-mph winds) that you never need to paint! Additional improvements include a new roof with transferable warranty, energy-efficient HVAC systems with Wi-Fi thermostats, and updated appliances—delivering durability and low-maintenance ownership so you can spend more time on the beach and less time working on your house. Let your imagination wander! Create your personalized island paradise, as the adjacent surveyed lot, cleared free of Brazilian pepper, provides valuable flexibility—ideal for lush gardens, a swimming pool, a 2nd guest house or creating an even larger private compound. Conveniently located near the beach access, ferry landing, and island amenities, this property has a history of strong rental potential. A rare opportunity to own a double-lot island home with upgrades, privacy, and expansion potential—all offered well below reconstruction cost. Schedule your private showing today and experience the island lifestyle firsthand!

4511 & 4501 Schooner Drive, Upper Captiva
$1,395,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026011545 MLS
An Island Masterpiece! This elegant, custom-designed island estate blends traditional island-style charm with contemporary sophistication. The home's exquisite detailing and bold roof lines create a unique and timeless design. Sited on an oversized lot close to gulf beaches on a quiet sandy lane. Hardie board siding, Pella impact windows, and electric storm shutters provide peace of mind. The private heated pool and screened outdoor entertainment area offer relaxation and island fun. Perfectly designed for high-volume vacation rentals. A grand two-story foyer welcomes you inside with an elegant winding wood staircase. Two spacious primary suites on the first level offer en suite baths with custom tile walk-in showers. The third guest bedroom enjoys its adjacent upgraded bath with a tub/shower. On the next level, the luxurious custom kitchen sparkles with granite countertops & stainless steel appliances. Deep dark wood cabinetry throughout the kitchen space offers elegantly curved corner cupboards for a sleek and functional appeal. Built-in yacht-style dining that seats 12+ in a three-side banquette uses the space ideally for entertaining. The living area meanders from the cozy TV/media area to covered screen porches and three levels of outdoor sundecks. Upstairs, the vaulted natural wood ceiling loft is a stunning focal point and versatile fourth sleeping space, offering gorgeous Gulf views through expansive sliding glass doors. Step up to the top lookout deck, where panoramic vistas of the Gulf and the island's natural beauty unfold. A rare blend of refined elegance and island serenity, this exceptional home is a magical seaside spot to enjoy your new island beach lifestyle.

4541 Conch Shell Drive, Captiva
$3,895,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 2026007775 MLS
Beauty & The Beach is one of the most extraordinary Gulf-front estate homes ever offered for sale on North Captiva Island! This custom-crafted contemporary residence sits on the central portion of the island's widest stretch of beach, providing greater long-term shoreline security and uninterrupted panoramic Gulf views. A proven luxury vacation rental leader, this home generated over $360k in gross rentals in 2021.  The property booked over $250k in gross rentals in 2025, even with downtime for repairs and upgrades.  This is a rare opportunity to acquire both a premier vacation retreat and a top-tier rental asset. Designed with a striking stucco exterior, impact-resistant glass throughout, and a private interior elevator serving all three levels, the home delivers refined coastal architecture paired with modern convenience. The ground-level area provides a bonus room & bunk area, plus an extensive outdoor entertainment space with a pool, patio, outdoor kitchen & poolside bar, all connected by a private walkway to the island's most pristine sugar-sand beach. Inside, every space is meticulously planned & designed for elevated entertaining & relaxed luxury. Highlights include a gourmet chef's kitchen, a dramatic dining room crowned by soaring barrel-vaulted ceilings, and a formal living area wrapped in panoramic glass. A built-in fireplace with television above the hearth anchors the living space with warmth and elegance.  The two primary living levels were designed to capture the spectacular Gulf and sunset views.   The 4 elegant bedroom suites provide marvelous spaces for you and your guests to experience five-star resort-style luxury sleeping accommodations. The top-level primary suite boasts panoramic beach views, an en suite bath with a walk-in shower, a dual-sink vanity, and a lockable owners' closet.  Imagine relaxing in the extra-deep soaking tub while you stare at the shimmering waters lapping the shoreline. The second primary suite, located just off the entertainment den/media room, offers excellent beach views & a luxury en suite bath with a walk-in shower. Two more north-facing guest suites create "family-suite-style" guest zones with a Gulf-facing King bed suite & en suite bath, plus an adjacent bedroom & bath.  Opportunities to acquire a Gulf-front estate of this caliber, location, and proven income performance are exceedingly rare on North Captiva Island. Beauty & The Beach represents the very best of luxury island living!

660 Gulf Lane, Upper Captiva
$634,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2025013135 MLS
Adorable island cottage on beautiful North Captiva Island with classic beach style. This bungalow offers three sleeping rooms, making great use of the space. The living room and kitchen area are full of charm with tongue-and-groove wood walls, an authentic coastal retreat style. The two levels of decking are great for watching sunsets and gathering with the family. The home is located on a valuable oversized lot, just a short stroll or golf cart ride to the nearest beach access. Plenty of room to add on or install a large pool and outdoor entertainment area. Impact windows and sliders throughout, plus new hardie-board siding. Don't miss out on the chance to affordably obtain your beach house dream goal on this one-of-a-kind island!

4561 Smugglers Drive, Upper Captiva
Start Your Search