Pine Island Village Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Pine Island Village Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Welcome to Pine Island Village, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of St. James City, Florida, within the picturesque Lee County. This enchanting non-gated community offers a unique blend of tranquility and convenience, making it the perfect sanctuary for those seeking a laid-back lifestyle amidst the beauty of Florida’s natural surroundings.

Pine Island Village is characterized by its charming homes that embody the essence of tropical living. Each residence is thoughtfully designed to provide comfort and style, with spacious layouts that invite an abundance of natural light. Whether you’re looking for a cozy retreat or a vibrant family home, Pine Island Village has something to suit every taste and preference.

One of the standout features of this community is its commitment to a friendly, neighborly atmosphere. Without the confines of a gated entrance, residents enjoy a sense of openness and connection with their surroundings. This fosters a welcoming environment where community members can engage in social activities, share stories, and build lasting friendships.

The location of Pine Island Village is another significant draw. Just a stone's throw away from the stunning beaches and serene waterfront, residents can indulge in a variety of outdoor activities, from fishing and boating to leisurely strolls along the shore. The nearby vibrant local shops and dining options add to the allure, ensuring that everything you need is within reach.

Experience the charm of Pine Island Village, where a relaxed lifestyle meets the beauty of Florida living. Your dream home awaits in this delightful community!

Newest Pine Island Village Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

St James City offers the old Florida lifestyle without all the traffic, high-rises and crowds. Get away from it all to a place that's a perfect island escape in Pine Island Village. St James City and Pine Island is perfect for boaters, fishing, and offer a tranquil coastal atmosphere. Pine Island Village has low HOA fees and still has a clubhouse and community pool for those sunny days. This lot is ready and waiting for you to build your home. Builders, this could be your next new construction project!

4416 Lake Heather Circle, St James City

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026018936 MLS

Charming Island Retreat in Pine Island Village with 1469 sq/ft with an additional Florida room adding up to 1640 sq/ft under air. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence is offered fully furnished with the perfect blend of comfort and coastal charm. High and Dry. Positioned on one of the highest points of the island, this home has never flooded and is not in a flood zone, providing added peace of mind. The kitchen features stylish cabinetry highlighted by custom shiplap accent walls and opens to the main living space, which boasts laminate flooring throughout, vaulted ceilings, and beautiful built-in cabinetry that adds elegance and functionality to the main living area. The third bedroom is currently being used as an office and features built-in cabinetry, offering a versatile space perfect for remote work or hobbies. Each bedroom includes a walk-in closet, ensuring ample storage for every room. Both bathrooms have been remodeled with unique mirror accents, and the primary en-suite features a built-in ceiling heater for added comfort. Step into the sunroom, a true highlight of the home, featuring brick flooring, a bamboo ceiling, and tranquil views of Lake Heather. It's the perfect spot to unwind, enjoy your morning coffee, entertain guests, or simply take in the breathtaking sunsets over the lake. Additional features include a 4-year-old roof, built-in smoke detectors, solar panels for energy efficiency, brand new washer and dryer that stay with the home, and a whole-home Aquasana water purifier system. Residents of Pine Island Village enjoy access to a community pool, and the location is just minutes from local shopping, dining, and all the island conveniences. Don’t miss the opportunity to own a slice of paradise in this welcoming island community!

4539 Pine Village Court, St James City

WELCOME TO PARADISE!! FANTASTIC LOCATION !! READY TO BUILD YOUR DREAM HOME!! If your looking for the tranquility of island life then this oversized lot on a quiet cul-de-sac in Pine Island Village is for you!! This is a wonderful, quaint, community & neighborhood where you can kick back and enjoy the Island Lifestyle. Low annual HOA fee which includes a lovely community pool & half basketball court. St. James City is on the south end of Pine Island. Pine Island is a great place for fishing enthusiasts and nature lovers & is known for its natural beauty, small-town atmosphere, and incredible sunrises and sunsets. Enjoy the charm of island living with laid-back vibes, local restaurants & shops, and easy access to world-class fishing, kayaking, and boating. Don’t miss your chance to own property in one of Southwest Florida’s hidden gems!

4460 Turtle Trail Lane, St James City

Stop Dreaming. Start Building. Island Life Begins Here. Tucked away on Pine Island, this rare .34-acre homesite is more than land — it’s the launchpad to a lifestyle most only dream of. No stoplights. No stress. Just sunsets, salty breezes, and the promise of a life that moves at the pace of peace. 4340 Turtle Trail Lane offers space to build your island escape — with low HOA fees, refurbished pool access, and lower-cost flood insurance thanks to its ideal location outside coastal zones. This lot sits 14 1/2 feet above sea level! Imagine this: • Sipping coffee under swaying palms • Golf cart rides to the local VFW or tiki bar • Fresh fish. Friendly faces. • A neighborhood where the loudest noise is laughter over dinner Island lots like this don’t last. Claim your slice of paradise before someone else builds the life you’re dreaming of.

4340 Turtle Trail Lane, St James City

Build Your Dream Home in Pine Island Village – .25 Acre Homesite Discover the perfect setting for your future home in Pine Island Village, a quiet and quaint community in Saint James City. This .25-acre homesite offers both charm and convenience, with paved, county-maintained roads and water and electric hookups available at the street. Residents of Pine Island Village enjoy neighborhood amenities including a half basketball court and a lovely community pool, creating a relaxing and welcoming atmosphere. With very low HOA fees of just $300 per year, you’ll appreciate the affordability and value of this community. For your peace of mind and planning ease, a boundary survey and architectural plans are already available. This property is an ideal opportunity to build in a tranquil location while still being close to all that Pine Island has to offer—fishing, boating, dining, and small-town coastal living.

4491 Pine Hill Court, St James City

Start Your Search

Brandon Reitz

Meet Brandon Reitz, a dynamic and accomplished millenial real estate agent who specializes in all types of investment properties. With an unwavering passion for the ever-evolving world of real estate, Brandon has established himself as a trusted advisor and a driving force within the industry. Armed with a deep understanding of the market trends and an innate ability to identify lucrative investment opportunities, Brandon has helped hundreds clients unlock their full potential in the realm of real estate investments. His keen eye for detail and meticulous research ensures that every client receives tailored strategies and comprehensive guidance throughout their investment journey. Brandon’s relentless pursuit of excellence is evident in his educational background and professional achievements. Holding a degree in Real Estate Finance and armed with a comprehensive knowledge of property management, financial analysis, and market dynamics, Brandon possesses the technical expertise necessary to navigate the intricacies of investment properties with finesse. What truly sets Brandon apart, however, is his unwavering commitment to his client's success. With a client-centric approach, he takes the time to truly understand each individual's unique goals, risk tolerance, and financial aspirations. By cultivating strong relationships built on trust, open communication, and transparency, Brandon ensures that his clients' investment strategies are aligned with their long-term objectives. Beyond his expertise and exceptional service, Brandon possesses an innate ability to connect with people on a personal level. Their warm demeanor, coupled with an unwavering dedication to client satisfaction, has earned him a stellar reputation as a real estate professional who goes above and beyond. In addition to his day-to-day responsibilities as a real estate agent, Brandon remains at the forefront of industry developments. He avidly follows market trends, attends industry conferences, and engages in continuous professional development to ensure he stays ahead of the curve. By leveraging cutting-edge technologies and innovative marketing strategies, Brandon harnesses every available tool to maximize his clients' investment potential. Outside of the real estate realm, Brandon enjoys giving back to the community and actively participates in various philanthropic initiatives. He firmly believes in the power of real estate as a means of empowering individuals and communities, and he consistently strives to make a positive impact beyond his professional pursuits. Whether you are a seasoned investor looking to expand your portfolio or a newcomer seeking expert guidance, Brandon is the trusted partner you need. His unparalleled knowledge, unwavering dedication, and genuine passion for real estate investments make him the go-to professional for all your investment property needs. Contact Brandon today to unlock the door to your investment success and embark on a transformative journey within the realm of real estate.

Learn More

Stephanie Baker

Stephanie is the heartbeat behind the day-to-day operations at both PineIslandVacations.com and Sea Glass Gulf Realty. Originally from Ohio, she traded snow for sunshine and brought her drive, positivity, and work ethic straight to Pine Island—where she’s been elevating the experience for clients, owners, and guests ever since. A true dynamo of energy and creativity, Stephanie thrives in the fast-paced world of property management and real estate. Her background in accounting gives her a sharp eye for detail and organization, ensuring everything runs smoothly behind the scenes—from financials to transactions to daily operations. But what really makes Stephanie invaluable is her people-first approach and deep-rooted island connections. She knows how to get things done, who to call, and how to make it happen—often before anyone else even realizes it’s needed. Whether she’s coordinating with vendors, assisting homeowners, or supporting agents, she brings a level of care, responsiveness, and personality that sets the tone for the entire office. Stephanie isn’t just keeping things running—she’s making them better, more efficient, and a whole lot more enjoyable along the way.

Learn More

Carolyn Creagh

Carolyn brings with her a true passion for island living and extensive knowledge of North Captiva Island and Southwest Florida’s coastal communities. Originally from Ohio, Carolyn followed her love for nature, boating, kayaking, fishing, and the peaceful island lifestyle to paradise — and now helps others do the same. As a resident and advocate of North Captiva Island, Carolyn understands firsthand what makes this bridgeless barrier island so special: privacy, tranquility, breathtaking natural beauty, and a lifestyle unlike anywhere else in Florida. Throughout her real estate career, Carolyn has been involved in the sale of some of the island’s most premier and sought-after properties, earning the trust of buyers and sellers looking for exceptional waterfront homes, luxury retreats, and unique island investments. Her warm personality, dedication to her clients, and genuine love for the community make her a perfect addition to the Sea Glass Gulf Realty team. Whether you’re searching for a waterfront retreat, vacation home, investment property, or your own slice of island paradise, Carolyn is ready to help make your dream a reality.

Learn More