Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$699,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026026864 MLS
Margaritas, sunsets, and island time await at this waterfront retreat in the heart of St. James City. Designed for those who dream of a laid-back tropical lifestyle, this elevated coastal home combines boating, entertaining, and carefree island living into one unforgettable package. The main living level features 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, and an open great room floor plan that flows seamlessly to the screened waterfront lanai. The beautifully remodeled primary suite offers a walk-in closet and spa-inspired bath featuring dual vanities, a custom walk-in shower with multiple shower heads, and a luxurious rain shower. The updated kitchen shines with quartz countertops, subway tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, upgraded hardware, and plenty of room for gathering with family and friends after a day on the water. Downstairs, guests will love the private bungalow-style suite complete with its own entrance, new mini-split system, updated cabinetry, vanity, lighting, and en-suite bath with walk-in shower. The lower level also offers an oversized 2-car garage with extended storage space for fishing gear, kayaks, golf cart, and all your island toys and workshop. Step outside to the screened pool area where colorful ocean-themed murals, tropical breezes, a private outdoor shower, and comfortable gathering spaces create a true vacation-at-home atmosphere. Outside, the property feels like a private botanical garden with mature palms, native landscaping, fruit trees, granite-lined flower beds, tiki lighting, solar accent lighting, irrigation system, and multiple outdoor entertaining spaces. Boaters will appreciate the covered 8K boat lift with newer canopy, fish-cleaning station, dock lighting, snook light, updated dock electrical, rewrapped pilings, and quick access to Pine Island Sound, world-class fishing, waterfront restaurants, secluded beaches, and the Gulf waters beyond. Extensively improved for peace of mind, major updates include a stone-coated metal roof rated for 200 mph winds (2023), hurricane impact windows and pocket slider (2026), new picture-window pool cage (2024), resurfaced pool with new tile (2023), raised HVAC equipment (2025), A/C system with warranty through 2028, elevated water heater, slab-jacked driveway and pool deck with lifetime warranty, new gutters, soffits and fascia, updated electrical, new insulation, fresh interior and exterior paint, remodeled primary bath, and numerous additional upgrades throughout. Whether you're boating to lunch, relaxing poolside under the tiki lights, or enjoying a sunset cocktail from the screened lanai, this island escape delivers the authentic Pine Island lifestyle you've been searching for.

2808 Sanibel Boulevard, St James City
$440,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026024360 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2.5 bath home in the heart of Saint James City, where comfort, style, and entertainment come together. Featuring an oversized master suite with two spacious walk-in closets, separate an oversize shower and stand alone tub with his & her sinks, this home offers the space and functionality today’s buyers are looking for. Recent improvements provide peace of mind, including a new roof, stucco siding, back deck with covered lanai & screen enclosure, impact-resistant windows and doors, new appliances, all new HVAC & ducking and a new water heater. The house is equipped with a whole house generator hook up plug. The range is propane fueled. Another standout feature is the massive open downstairs area which is an incredible space perfect for entertaining, hosting game nights, creating a home theater, setting up a billiards room, or accommodating additional guests. The possibilities are endless. An air-conditioned garage adds valuable flexibility for hobbies, storage, a workshop, or fitness space. Outside, you’ll find a private backyard designed for enjoying the Florida lifestyle, with plenty of room for outdoor dining, gatherings, and enjoying your own tropical oasis, which has a irrigation system & outdoor landscape lighting as well. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, vacation getaway, or the ultimate place to entertain family and friends, this exceptional Saint James City home is basically a brand new home ready to enjoy! This house is a walk, bike ride, golfcart ride away from all that Saint James City has to offer. Including, a community park, bars & restaurants, marinas and plenty of events that are scheduled periodically throughout the year. Additional property available for purchase on west side of residence (Located behind house).

2551 Tamarind Street, St James City
$1,999,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026002528 MLS
With unobstructed views of the bay, perfectly framed by the tropical landscape, this residence embodies the essence of waterfront living. Upon entering the main level, you will be greeted by an abundance of natural light and vistas complimenting the fireplace in a harmonious blend of coastal and classic design. Entertain family and friends in the formal dining area or the main level balconies overlooking your backyard as dolphins swim in the background. The kitchen boasts views of the bay and offers plenty of cabinet and counterspace, a gas range and a wet bar that connects the kitchen to the family room. The primary quarters offer two walk in closets and a spacious bedroom surrounded by mature landscaping that integrates with the natural beauty of the surroundings. The well appointed guest bedrooms, one on the main level and the other on the first floor, award your guests with privacy. On the first floor you'll find a separate sitting room, a den (which the owners used as an exercise room) and a laundry room with an extra refrigerator and sink. From the office and recreation rooms you can step outside onto the expansive patio, where the beauty of coastal living truly comes to life. Sip cocktails as you watch boats glide across the bay, or indulge in alfresco dining under the pergola covered in blooming flowers. This waterfront setting offers endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, from kayaking and paddleboarding to fishing and birdwatching. The boating community of St. James City is conveniently located a short boat ride away from the Sanibel Causeway and beaches to the south and to the north, through Pine Island Sound, to the world famous Cabbage Key, Useppa Island, and Boca Grande pass. Whether appreciating some of the most pristine natural habitats in SWFL, sport fishing for tarpon or bar hoping by water, the options are endless

3569 San Carlos Drive, St James City
$2,750,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2025021960 MLS
RARE ST. JAMES CITY WATERFRONT ESTATE WITH OPEN BAY VIEWS, NO BRIDGES TO THE GULF Buy before the end of 2026 for potential property tax savings, and start the new year in one of Southwest Florida's most breathtaking waterfront settings. This fully renovated estate sits on the open waters of San Carlos Bay at the southern tip of Pine Island, delivering sweeping, unobstructed bay views, unforgettable sunsets, and protected deep-water Gulf access with no bridges & true Old Florida island living at its best. $400,000+ in renovations means this home is as move-in ready as it is beautiful: new roof, full spray-foam insulation, hurricane-impact windows and doors, whole-home generator, updated HVAC and ductwork, instant hot water heaters, wide-plank tile flooring, and custom closets throughout. Built for boaters: a private dock with two brand-new boat lifts - 6,000-lb and 15,000-lb - puts the Gulf of Mexico minutes from your back door. Outdoor living that steals the show: a heated pool and spa overlooking the bay, a custom tiki hut, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen made for sunset entertaining. Inside, the coastal-inspired kitchen is the heart of the home with JennAir appliances, exotic granite countertops, and over $250,000 in custom cabinetry. Offered turnkey and tastefully furnished in a Tommy Bahama style (with exclusions), this home is ready for its next chapter. An oversized four-car garage with epoxy flooring adds room for up to six vehicles plus additional storage. Luxury renovations, energy efficiency, unmatched boating access, and some of the best open-water views in Southwest Florida, all in one rare St. James City estate. Schedule your private showing today and see San Carlos Bay living for yourself.

3807 San Carlos Drive, St James City
$2,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2025009639 MLS
A peaceful, modern, and comfortable lifestyle that is an effortless extension of its natural surroundings. Tucked deep in the Florida pines and palmettos on 10 dry acres with no wetlands, backing up to a 567-acre protected preserve, this 7,500 SF Modern Farmhouse is one of the most architecturally striking and structurally sound homes for sale. Constructed with solid concrete on both floors, PGT hurricane windows and doors, and red iron structural steel. Years of design, engineering, and lifestyle come together. Custom iron front doors, redwood walls, a custom welded staircase, and an Edison bulb chandelier. Everything is intentional. A 4,000 SF 1st floor features the primary suite and bedrooms. A 3,500 SF 2nd floor living space with a flex room/studio offers an open concept w/ dedicated spaces for dining & entertaining. No other home offers this balance of togetherness and privacy. Dolby Atmos theater w/ a 126-inch digital 8K projection screen rivaling commercial theaters. Cambria Quartz counters, modern art, steel beams, and concrete meet mature trees, private walking paths, a 3/4-acre pond, and ATV trails. A dedicated wine room w/ wine racks & shelving for stouts. Restaurant-style full bar w/ Zephyr full-size appliances. A whole-home 10-zone independent audio AV system with JBL speakers & Crown amplifiers. Built for those who want to live, work, and play! Bunker-strength construction, tech room, dedicated Xfinity pedestal & LCEC transformer, and underground utilities. The property has a 9.9 ft elevation - NEVER flooded. The RV garage is 70x30, totaling 2,100 SF, with 28-ft ceilings and drive-through access for 60+-ft RVs. Ideal for car collecting and boat storage, with 3 12x14 ft custom roll-up overhead doors, front & rear concrete pads, prewired for a 20-amp exhaust system, speaker system, epoxy floor, high-bay lighting, 400-amp electrical service, and industrial fans. Private road. ATVs, golf carts, horses, and a shooting/firing range all ok. BOATERS: Marinas 5 min. away & marinas at both ends of the island, boat launches, and easy water access. Four Winds Marina provides ample dry storage options. From here Cayo Costa, Useppa Island, Boca Grande, world-class tarpon fishing, and pristine barrier island beaches. Island dining with local favorites including Blue Dog Bar & Grill, the Yucatan Waterfront Tiki Bar & Grill, and legendary Tarpon Lodge — a hidden waterfront gem offering fine dining. Just over the bridge: The Seven Islands Project includes a Marriott-branded hotel, restaurants, a tiki bar, marina & boat slips, and a lagoon resort beach. Plus an outdoor amphitheater, community center, splash pad, kayak launch, dog park, and a food truck park. Cape Coral Grove will deliver a national grocer, local and national dining, retail, a luxury hotel, premium apartments, 4 public parks, and farmers' markets.

4412 Pinetree Boulevard, St James City
$1,470,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2025000268 MLS
Beautiful home south end of the island! Poured concrete construction, a metal roof , minutes to Sanibel beachs , ADA Accessible home* Sunrise and Sunset views , fire sprinkler system *Elevator- #900 capacity Impact resistant doors & windows. *1000 sq ft of 'man cave' next to the garage + apartment w/ bedroom & kitchen *Each level has a bedroom suite. Top floor master suite- best views on the island- kitchenette, walk-in shower, soaking tub. Main level, 2nd floor- outdoor gas grill hook up, fireplace, plantation shutters, the kitchen: double oven & gas range. Pool & HotTub: Heated/saltwater/self cleaning. One of the most well built homes in SWFL.. Generator hook ups. Deep canal direct access to the gulf. Covered 10000 lb boat lift & jet ski lift on dock. Every room has waterviews! St. James City has bars, restaurants, seafood markets, farm fresh markets, fishing & access to the best beaches minutes away!

3430 1st Avenue, St James City