St James City Homes for Sale

St James City Homes for Sale

Welcome to St. James City, a hidden gem nestled on Pine Island in Lee County, Florida. This charming community offers a unique blend of laid-back island living and vibrant local culture, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a tranquil lifestyle without sacrificing access to modern conveniences.

St. James City is renowned for its breathtaking waterfront views, abundant wildlife, and a plethora of outdoor activities. Whether you’re an avid fisherman, a boating enthusiast, or simply enjoy the beauty of nature, you’ll find your paradise here. The area is surrounded by lush mangroves and pristine waters, providing endless opportunities for kayaking, paddleboarding, and exploring the scenic coastline. The local community is warm and welcoming, with a variety of shops, restaurants, and galleries that showcase the artistic spirit of the island.

For those considering a move to this idyllic location, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From charming single-family homes with tropical landscaping to luxurious waterfront properties with private docks, St. James City has something for everyone. Imagine waking up to stunning sunrises over the water or enjoying an evening stroll along the beach, all while being part of a close-knit community.

With its serene environment and an array of recreational activities, St. James City is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. If you’re ready to discover your dream home in this beautiful coastal paradise, explore the homes for sale today and take the first step towards your new life in St. James City!

Newest St James City Homes for Sale

$699,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026037908 MLS
Lovely 2 bedroom-2 bath pool home in highly sought after Bayview Acres. Very quick boating access to Pine Island Sound and the Gulf of America! Beautiful heated pool with spa and large screened pool lanai. 2 boat lifts. One is covered. Home was remodeled in 2021. Propane kitchen stove and propane "on-demand" hot water heater. Floors are 48"x 24" beautiful tile throughout the home. Kitchen appliances are Samsung with white glass fronts. The dining area looks out the sliders to the waterfront! All the windows and doors are hurricane impact glass! New metal roof in 2024. This home is immaculate and is being sold turnkey! All furnishings are included! What more could you ask for??!!

3681 Ruby Avenue, St James City
$399,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026038314 MLS
Welcome to Pine Island! Bring your boat, trailer, camper, and a toothbrush! Enjoy a relaxed lifestyle in the heart of beautiful St. James City! This TURNKEY furnished elevated stilt home sits on almost one-third of an acre and offers a wonderful combination of space, privacy, accessibility, and location. The home features a fenced backyard with a double gate, making it easy to bring in a boat, RV, trailer, or other recreational toys. With no HOA and no restrictions on storing boats or RVs, you have the freedom to truly enjoy your property and the Southwest Florida lifestyle. St. James City is golf-cart friendly, and you’re just a quick ride from local restaurants, bars, and shopping. The neighborhood is perfect for walking the dog, riding bikes, or simply enjoying the laid-back pace of island living. The St. James City Civic Center is less than a block away, offering a park and a variety of activities and entertainment for both children and adults. This home is also designed with accessibility and comfort in mind. An exterior lift provides convenient access from the ground level to the spacious upstairs screened porch, making the home handicap accessible. The home offers two screened porches—one conveniently located off the garage and another upstairs where you can truly take advantage of the beautiful Florida weather. The upstairs porch faces east and offers must-see sunrise views. Sliders open from the porch into the bedroom, living room, and dining room, creating a wonderful connection between indoor and outdoor living. Inside, the main living area thoughtfully separates the bedrooms, providing additional privacy for family and guests. Recent updates include a new metal roof and electrical panel with new receptacles in 2023, along with hurricane windows and a hurricane-rated garage door for added peace of mind. The front staircase and rear steps feature durable composite decking for easy maintenance. With nearly one-third of an acre, a fenced yard, no HOA restrictions, great accessibility, multiple outdoor living spaces, and a location close to everything St. James City has to offer, this is a home that makes it easy to embrace the island lifestyle.

2510 Rose Avenue, St James City
$869,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026037659 MLS
Highest Point on the Island, NO flooding, NO hurricane Damage and newer metal roof! A rare opportunity to own a completely renovated private estate nestled on nearly five acres in the heart of St. James City. From the moment you enter through the gated entrance, a long private driveway winds through beautifully landscaped grounds and this exceptional property makes a statement, surrounded by extensive landscaping and an impressive collection of tropical palms that create a private, resort-like setting. Completely renovated throughout, this three-bedroom, two-bath compound offers approximately 2,004 square feet of beautifully designed living space, blending refined finishes with the relaxed sophistication of island living. The master bedroom has a private spa like bathroom with a soaking tub and separate shower. The chefs kitchen has been tastefully designed and offers an open layout perfect for entertaining! The triple sliders in the living room offer a very welcoming island breeze! This home offers 2 special things you don't find often, an ELEVATOR so you don't have walk the steps up and also a conveyor belt for your groceries!!! This 2 story home also offers screened lanai and balcony with high end epoxy flooring. This makes for watching those island sunsets so peaceful with your tranquil surroundings. You will also find Beyond the residence, plenty of rooms for all your fruit trees. A serene private pond and dramatic custom rock waterfall create an unforgettable tropical backdrop, while the expansive acreage offers privacy, beauty and ENDLESS possibilities. Car enthusiasts and collectors will appreciate the impressive six-car garage, providing extraordinary space for vehicles, toys, boats a workshop or stables!! With coveted Stringfellow Road frontage, nearly five acres of beautifully landscaped grounds, AG-2 agricultural zoning and a gated setting, this estate offers a level of versatility and privacy that is increasingly difficult to find. More than a home, this is a private tropical retreat where lush palms, water features, expansive grounds and exceptional amenities come together to create one of St. James City’s most distinctive acreage properties. This compounds offers luxury living and peaceful island living.

3989 Sunshine Boulevard, St James City
$525,888
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026037079 MLS
Welcome to this incredibly charming turn key furnished waterfront cottage paradise! Tucked beneath sprawling oaks, mature mahoganies and swaying palms, this secluded St. James City retreat offers nearly half an acre of shaded, private waterfront bliss — yet it's just minutes from some of the island's favorite restaurants, bars, and local hangouts. And did we mention the privacy? The property feels like your own tropical hideaway. Watch manatees and dolphins cruise the canal from your backyard, cast a line, or grill the catch of the day after bringing it in from your own 30-foot dock. Not fishing today? Two nearby fresh seafood markets make it easy to bring home the day's local catch. And if outdoor living is your thing, Enjoy mornings on your two screened porches — one overlooking the expansive backyard and waterfront, and another facing the large front yard. Morning coffee, afternoon cocktails, or a quiet evening outdoors — you've got the perfect spot for every mood. Inside, the cottage has been updated while keeping its unmistakable Old Florida beach-house character. The large butcher block kitchen island provides plenty of room for friends and family to gather for drinks, dinner, and fish stories, while the spacious living area keeps everything comfortable and inviting. One of the home's most memorable features is beneath your feet: unique hand-painted wood floors running throughout the cottage. Creative, colorful, and easy to maintain, they're almost guaranteed to become a conversation piece the moment guests walk through the door. The oversized primary bedroom offers a built-in vanity and two large closets, while the second bedroom has a generous closet of its own. The bathroom features a roomy walk-in tile shower, tile flooring, and a corner linen cabinet with deep shelving. The updated laundry room includes a newer front-loading washer and dryer, a new water heater, a generous butcher block folding counter, and upper cabinetry. When you're ready to explore, simply walk out to your dock, step aboard the boat, and go. From your backyard, it's approximately a fifteen-minute canal ride through beautiful mangroves, with incredible fishing, bird watching, and Southwest Florida nature along the way. Continue into Pine Island Sound, and a whole new world opens up — Sanibel, Fort Myers Beach, gulf waters, waterfront restaurants, and countless places to explore by boat. Or don't go anywhere at all. Fire up the grill, grab a cold drink, and enjoy the shade beneath the trees while boats, dolphins, and manatees pass by. This is exactly the Pine Island lifestyle people come for.

3300 6th Avenue, St James City
$359,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026035749 MLS
BRING THE BOAT, TRAILER, KAYAKS & ALL THE TOYS! Welcome to 3680 Mango Street in St. James City, where laid-back island living meets flexibility and opportunity. With no HOA, the property offers potential for short-term or vacation rental use. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, island getaway, or potential income-producing property, this one gives you options. Featuring two primary suites, the layout is ideal for hosting family, friends, or guests, while the air-conditioned Florida room provides additional usable living space. This is the Pine Island lifestyle people come here for! Bring the boat and trailer, load up the kayaks, and spend your days on the water. Explore Pine Island Sound, fish some of Southwest Florida's legendary waters, kayak the mangroves, bike the island, visit nearby preserves, or head out by boat toward Cayo Costa, Cabbage Key, Captiva, and Sanibel Islands. Back on land, enjoy St. James City's waterfront restaurants, marinas, fishing charters, live music, and unmistakable colorful Old Florida atmosphere. No HOA. Room for the toys. Close to the water. Pure Pine Island living. Discover the possibilities at 3680 Mango Street.

3680 Mango Street, St James City
$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026037149 MLS
WIDE LAKE VIEWS, A BRAND NEW 2026 KITCHEN AND PEACEFUL PINE ISLAND LIVING! Welcome to Pine Island Village in Saint James City, where tranquil water views, an open layout and the relaxed charm of Old Florida come together in this beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offering 1,553 square feet of living space on a .25 acre homesite. Positioned on one of the higher elevations on the island and located in Flood Zone X, the home sustained no damage from recent storms, offering added peace of mind. Inside, the bright great room features tile flooring throughout, tray ceilings, abundant natural light and expansive lake views. At the heart of the home is the completely remodeled kitchen, NEW IN 2026, featuring white shaker cabinetry, striking stone countertops with a matching full height backsplash, an oversized island with plenty of prep and seating space, farmhouse style sink, stainless steel appliances, wall ovens, cooktop, pot filler, modern black hardware and generous storage. A large window overlooking the lake brings the peaceful setting right into the kitchen, while the open design flows easily into the living and dining areas. The spacious primary suite features a tray ceiling, private access to the screened lanai and an en suite bath with dual vanities, ample cabinetry and a walk in tiled shower. Two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, a home office or hobby space, while the guest bath offers a granite vanity, tub and shower combination and convenient exterior access. Step outside to the screened and pavered lanai overlooking the expansive backyard and lake, an ideal place to enjoy quiet mornings and peaceful evenings. Additional features include a metal roof, impact rated windows and doors, a pavered driveway and a two car garage. Pine Island Village is a small, friendly community with a low HOA of just $350 per year, a community pool, basketball court and walking areas. Beyond the neighborhood, Pine Island offers a slower paced Old Florida lifestyle surrounded by tropical farms, native wildlife and natural beauty, while still putting you close to local restaurants, live music, art, world class fishing, boating and ferry access to the surrounding barrier islands. COME EXPERIENCE THE SPACE, WATER VIEWS AND LAID BACK ISLAND LIFESTYLE THAT MAKE THIS HOME SO SPECIAL!

4507 Lake Heather Circle, St James City
$749,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026036197 MLS
Exciting new-construction opportunity at 5288 Fairbanks Drive in St. James City! Construction is underway on this thoughtfully designed residence featuring three bedrooms, a versatile den, three full bathrooms, and a private pool. Buyers may still have an opportunity to personalize select finishes, including interior and exterior colors, cabinetry, and flooring, depending on the construction schedule and builder deadlines. The flexible floor plan provides comfortable space for everyday living, entertaining, working from home, and accommodating overnight guests. The spacious homesite offers many possibilities beyond the planned pool and outdoor living area, with potential room for RV or boat parking, additional storage, or future improvements! Located within the relaxed Pine Island community, this home offers easy access to the coastal lifestyle for which St. James City is known, including boating, fishing, local dining, and nearby marinas. Whether you envision a full-time residence or seasonal retreat, this is an exciting opportunity to make a brand-new Southwest Florida home your own. Construction is currently in progress. Plans, dimensions, finishes, features, pricing, and estimated completion dates are subject to change. Available selections depend on the stage of construction and builder approval. Buyers should independently verify all specifications, permitted uses, selection options, and completion timelines.

5288 Fairbanks Drive, St James City
$4,250,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 226030290 MLS
Welcome to an extraordinary waterfront estate where 3.4 acres, exceptional boating access and resort-style living come together in one remarkable property. With approximately 1,561 feet of deep-water canal frontage, commanding wide-water views and boating access leading out to the harbor and beyond, this is the kind of Southwest Florida estate that immediately stands apart. Enter through the gated entrance and follow an over 1,500-foot driveway lined with royal palms to this custom Stearns-built residence, offered fully furnished. Inside, the dramatic great room rises approximately 21 feet, with a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, walls of glass, maple ceilings, cherry built-ins and an impressive open staircase. High-end craftsmanship and substantial architectural details carry throughout the home. A dedicated office and separate media room provide spaces designed specifically for working from home and relaxing or entertaining. Open the walls of glass and the property transforms into a waterfront resort. The expansive lanai overlooks a zero-edge infinity pool and whirlpool, with a full outdoor kitchen, cypress ceilings, fire feature and generous entertaining areas. Watch manatees move through the canal, dolphins pass the dock and boats cruise by while entertaining poolside. From sunrise coffee by the water to sunset cocktails around the pool, this is a home built for the Florida lifestyle—where weekends feel like vacations and the hardest decision may be whether to take the boat or the golf cart. For boaters and anglers, a custom boathouse features a captain's walk and an 8,000-pound boat lift, while a 90-foot dock provides additional room for larger or visiting vessels. From here, explore Pine Island Sound, Sanibel, Captiva, Cayo Costa, Cabbage Key and the Gulf, with world-class fishing, waterfront restaurants and island destinations accessible by boat. The infrastructure behind the lifestyle is equally impressive, with impact windows, a whole-home and pool equipment generator, whole-house dehumidification system, 1,000-gallon buried propane tank, multi-zone air conditioning and ultra-high-speed internet connectivity. Even more impressive for a waterfront estate of this scale, current flood insurance is less than $1,700 annually. Two garages accommodate six vehicles, with high ceilings offering the potential to add lifts—an incredible setup for the car enthusiast, collector or anyone who needs room for the toys. Located just one mile from the heart of Saint James City, you can hop on your golf cart and enjoy local restaurants, bars, marinas and the laid-back island atmosphere that makes this community so unique. The real story here is difficult to duplicate: 3.4 acres, 1,561 feet of waterfront, serious boating infrastructure, a custom estate and resort-style outdoor living in one of Southwest Florida's most distinctive boating communities. After all, why own any old waterfront home when you can own one that people truly remember?

2755 & 2785 Cussell Drive, St James City
$459,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026036307 MLS
Some homes are simply well maintained—3742 Tangelo Drive is maintained to an entirely different standard. Its immaculate condition, thoughtful upgrades and unmistakable pride of ownership immediately set it apart. Built in 2016 on an oversized 0.31-acre lot in St. James City’s Tropical Homesites neighborhood, this exceptional 1,553-square-foot home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a 2-car garage, quality, comfort and authentic island living. Constructed of concrete block with impact-resistant windows and doors, the home is topped with a new standing-seam metal roof. The homesite was also extensively filled and elevated well beyond basic building requirements. This elevated, storm-conscious home is about as well prepared as island living gets—and has no history of flooding. A paver driveway creates a polished first impression. Inside, high ceilings, tall doorways and high-end tile flooring create a bright, open and welcoming atmosphere. Every room feels clean, spacious and thoughtfully finished. The kitchen features granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances and plenty of space for preparing meals and entertaining. Granite surfaces and refined finishes continue into the bathrooms. The spacious primary suite provides a comfortable retreat with two walk-in closets, dual vanities and a large walk-in shower. Both guest bedrooms are generously sized, offering flexibility for visitors, an office or hobbies. The home may also be purchased fully or partially furnished, if desired, making the transition to island living even easier. Florida living truly shines outside. Relax on the screened lanai or entertain around the new custom outdoor kitchen, complete with granite countertops, a built-in gas grill, refrigerator and sink. It is ready for weekend cookouts, evening gatherings and effortless outdoor dining. The large lot offers an uncommon sense of space, while the meticulously maintained exterior perfectly complements the pristine interior. Tropical Point Park and its waterfront beach area are within walking distance, placing kayaking, fishing, picnics and unforgettable sunsets just moments away. Beyond the park is Pine Island’s wonderfully unconventional character—a place where working waterfronts, tropical fruit groves, roadside produce stands, local artists, fishing boats and colorful personalities remain part of everyday life. Days move at their own pace, neighbors wave as they pass and flip-flops are appropriate almost everywhere. It is Old Florida with a little quirk, a lot of personality and none of the polished sameness found elsewhere. This is more than a move-in-ready home—it is an opportunity to own an exceptionally cared-for, thoughtfully constructed property in a lifestyle increasingly difficult to find. With its premium improvements, elevated homesite, storm-conscious construction, outstanding outdoor living spaces and distinctly Pine Island setting, 3742 Tangelo Drive stands apart from the competition.

3742 Tangelo Drive, St James City
$425,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026034608 MLS
Tired of South Florida's high home prices and traffic snarls? Relocate to bucolic Pine Island on Florida's Southwest Coast. Take a step back into Old Florida amidst soaring pine trees, hiking trails, spectacular sunsets, mango groves, and palm farms. This quiet, peaceful home offers lovely pastoral views on two sides, making you feel like you are in the middle of the country with unrestricted views of local farmland and cows. It is a true nature lover's paradise with more backyard birds than you will find on an Audubon walk. Yet, you are just moments away from a vibrant live music and art scene, great fishing, birding, boating, and ferry service to surrounding barrier islands. Set on 0.27 acres, this 1,500-square-foot property sits in a friendly neighborhood of about 40 homes with a low HOA. Residents enjoy amenities like a basketball court and a community pool that was recently improved. Virtually everything inside and out has been remodeled since 2018. The home features a two-bedroom, two-bathroom split floor plan that feels almost like having two primary suites, plus an ample den that could serve as a third bedroom while still leaving room for a study. The open layout boasts neutral interior paint, tile floors, and LED lighting throughout. The new kitchen and bathrooms showcase custom cabinetry, a large pantry, and tall, low-water-use toilets. An electric fireplace was recently added to the living room, which also benefits from a natural solar light. Solid core doors and ceiling fans in every room enhance the comfort of the home. The den, with large impact windows, functions as an extension of the main living space and is currently set up with two desk spaces, making it ideal for remote work. Even the garage is heated and air-conditioned, featuring custom cabinets and abundant inside storage. This home is built like a fortress when it comes to hurricanes, offering absolute peace of mind. Situated on one of the highest points on the island, it requires no flood insurance and experienced no flooding during recent storms. It is equipped with a new metal roof, hurricane-resistant windows, and a whole-house generator. Energy efficiency is a priority, resulting in low electric bills and low A/C costs. The exterior is designed for low-maintenance living, featuring a drought-resistant Provista grass lawn and an irrigation sprinkler system hooked up to a private well. Additional upgrades include covered and open patios, Leaf Filter gutters with buried drains, an antenna in the attic, an outside storage shed for garden supplies, and rainwater storage for inside plants.

4472 Lake Heather Circle, St James City
$725,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026034614 MLS
Welcome to waterfront living in St. James City! Situated on a spacious oversized corner lot, this beautifully remodeled waterfront home combines an open, inviting floor plan with expansive water views and the indoor/outdoor lifestyle Southwest Florida is known for. Remodeled in 2017, the home features tile flooring throughout, creating a clean, cohesive feel ideal for waterfront living. The heart of the home is the open-concept great room and kitchen, featuring white raised-panel wood cabinetry, marble countertops, stainless steel appliances, a large center island and pantry with convenient pull-out shelving. An entire wall of sliders opens the great room to an incredibly spacious screened lanai that extends nearly the full length of the home, seamlessly expanding the living and entertaining space outdoors while overlooking the water. The primary suite offers a double-door entry and private en suite bath featuring marble countertops, a remodeled walk-in shower, dual-sink vanity, linen closet and walk-in closet. Two additional guest bedrooms share a convenient Jack-and-Jill bath with a walk-in shower and marble countertop, while an additional half bath located off the kitchen is perfect for guests. Outside, the oversized corner lot provides plenty of room to enjoy the Florida sunshine, room to add a pool and a separate outdoor storage shed for all your boating, fishing and island gear. A large waterfront tiki overlooking the length of the canal creates the perfect setting for entertaining, sunset cocktails or simply relaxing by the water. The seawall has been reinforced, adding another valuable waterfront improvement. Additional peace-of-mind features include a new metal roof installed in 2023 and impact windows and doors throughout, with the exception of the front entry door, which is protected by an accordion hurricane shutter. No floodwater from any storm has entered the living area of the home. For the boater and angler, this is where the St. James City lifestyle truly comes alive, complete with a fish-cleaning station for the day's catch. Spend your days cruising the surrounding waterways, heading out to Pine Island Sound and the Gulf, fishing some of Southwest Florida's renowned waters, or island hopping to Sanibel, Captiva, North Captiva, Cayo Costa and Boca Grande. Whether your perfect day means chasing snook and redfish, pulling up to a waterfront restaurant or dropping anchor at a secluded beach, it's all within reach. With its 3-bedroom layout, multiple baths, expansive indoor/outdoor entertaining areas, waterfront tiki and desirable boating location, the property also offers exciting vacation rental or investment potential, providing flexibility to enjoy it as your own island retreat, an income-producing property, or a combination of both.

2498 Sapodilla Lane, St James City
$459,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026034789 MLS
Peaceful Island Retreat Escape to your own slice of Peaceful Island Paradise! Tucked away on the southern end of Pine Island and nestled along saltwater-fed Lake Castile, this beautifully maintained 2019 home offers the privacy, tranquility, and laid-back lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of—while keeping boating, dining, nature, and island entertainment just minutes away. Inside, the modern coastal design is filled with natural light thanks to an abundance of windows and features an open floor plan with soaring ceilings, a gorgeous living room with a gas fireplace, and an eat-in chef’s kitchen complete with a gas range. The spacious primary suite is joined by a junior primary suite, making this home ideal for guests or multi-generational living. Outside is where island living truly shines. Spend lazy afternoons lounging by the pool, enjoy happy hour overlooking the lake, and take in Pine Island’s spectacular sunsets surrounded by mature trees and native wildlife. And for the ultimate retreat, the property includes an air-conditioned she-shed—the perfect private space for a home office, creative studio, hobby room, reading retreat, or simply your own place to escape. The oversized garage features built-in cabinetry and a dedicated workshop area, while ample parking makes entertaining easy. Additional highlights include a propane tankless water heater, propane dryer, impact windows and doors throughout, and a durable metal roof. Best of all, you’re just 5 minutes from a marina and boat launch, with nature trails and preserves within walking distance and local restaurants offering live entertainment nearby. Come discover the peaceful island life you’ve been waiting for—where every day feels like a getaway!

3400 Coquina Lane, St James City
Start Your Search